Skip to main content
global settings
Sales
United States Homes for Sale
Atlanta Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
Austin Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
Boston Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Chicago Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
Dallas Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
Las Vegas Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
Miami Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
New York City Apartments for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
Philadelphia Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
Washington DC Homes for Sale
All Listings
Open Houses
Price Reduced
New Listings
Sold Listings
Rentals
United States Homes For Rent
Atlanta Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Austin Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Boston Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Chicago Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Dallas Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Las Vegas Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Miami Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
New York City Apartments for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Philadelphia Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Washington DC Homes for Rent
All Listings
Open Houses
New Listings
Buildings
All Buildings
New Home Communities
Single Family
Condo/Townhouse
Adult/Senior Communities
Locations
Agents
United States Real Estate Agents
Atlanta Real Estate Agents
Austin Real Estate Agents
Boston Real Estate Agents
Chicago Real Estate Agents
Dallas Real Estate Agents
Las Vegas Real Estate Agents
Miami Real Estate Agents
New York Real Estate Agents
Philadelphia Real Estate Agents
Washington DC Real Estate Agents
City Sites
CityHomes
Atlanta
Austin
Boston
Chicago
Dallas
Las Vegas
Miami
New York City
Philadelphia
Washington DC
Products
Agents
Brokers
Franchises
Display Your Listings
Shelter Island South
(0)
Status
(0)
Price
(0)
Bedrooms
(0)
Bathrooms
(0)
Type
(0)
Square Feet
(0)
Amenities
(0)
Acres
(0)
Virtual
(0)
Other
(0)
Keyword
26 Homes for Sale
in Shelter Island South
Gallery
Hybrid
Map
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
33
new listing 7 days ago
Shelter Island
44 St Marys Road
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
3
Bd
4
Ba
3,225
SF
Single Family
$3,900,000
$1,209
/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:
6/20/2024
$3,900,000
date
Price
variance
type
6/20/2024
$3,900,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
6
new listing 18 days ago
Shelter Island
3 S Cartwright Road
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
Land
$750,000
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:
6/9/2024
$750,000
date
Price
variance
type
6/9/2024
$750,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
36
new listing 19 days ago
Shelter Island
45 New York Avenue
Shelter Island
,
NY
11965
4
Bd
2
Ba
2,628
SF
Single Family
$2,495,000
$949
/SF
Listing by: Brown Harris Stevens (East Hampton)
Listed:
6/8/2024
$2,495,000
date
Price
variance
type
6/8/2024
$2,495,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
27
new listing 22 days ago
Shelter Island
3 Crab Creek Road
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
3
Bd
3
Ba
1,400
SF
Single Family
$2,195,000
$1,568
/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:
6/5/2024
$2,195,000
date
Price
variance
type
6/5/2024
$2,195,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
36
new listing 30 days ago
Shelter Island
4 Gazon Road
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
6
Bd
4
Ba
3,764
SF
Single Family
$3,385,000
$899
/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:
5/28/2024
$3,385,000
date
Price
variance
type
5/28/2024
$3,385,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
12
new listing 35 days ago
Shelter Island
24 Rocky Point Road
Shelter Island
,
NY
11939
4
Bd
3
Ba
3,000
SF
Single Family
$3,600,000
$1,200
/SF
Listing by: M WEIN REALTY INC
Listed:
5/23/2024
$3,600,000
date
Price
variance
type
5/23/2024
$3,600,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
36
Shelter Island
8 Crescent Way
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
4
Bd
3
Ba
2,800
SF
Single Family
$2,690,000
$961
/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:
5/10/2024
$2,690,000
date
Price
variance
type
5/10/2024
$2,690,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
29
Sale Under Contract 05-22-24
Shelter Island
18 Dickerson Drive
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
4
Bd
3
Ba
2,774
SF
Single Family
$2,495,000
$899
/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Contract:
5/22/2024
$2,495,000
date
Price
variance
type
5/22/2024
$2,495,000
--
Contract
5/4/2024
$2,495,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
26
Shelter Island
7 Marc Street
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
3
Bd
2
Ba
1,190
SF
Single Family
$1,800,000
$1,513
/SF
Listing by: Brown Harris Stevens (Sag Harbor)
Listed:
4/21/2024
$1,800,000
date
Price
variance
type
4/21/2024
$1,800,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
5
Open House
4-6-24
|
1:00 PM - 3:00 PM
Shelter Island
21 Signs Road
Shelter Island
,
NY
10314
2
Bd
1
Ba
750
SF
Condominium
$569,000
$759
/SF
Listing by: Exit Realty Professionals
Listed:
4/1/2024
$569,000
date
Price
variance
type
4/1/2024
$569,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
11
For Sale Price Reduced 06-02-24
Shelter Island
1048 Post Avenue
Shelter Island
,
NY
10302
7
Bd
3
Ba
1,984
SF
Single Family
$780,000
$393
/SF
Listing by: RE/MAX Edge
decreased:
6/2/2024
$780,000
(2.49%)
date
Price
variance
type
6/2/2024
$780,000
-2.49%
decreased
5/2/2024
$799,900
+9.73%
Listed
4/16/2024
$729,000
--
off market
2/27/2024
$729,000
--
Listed
Images
ContactInfo
Map
1
of
5
Shelter Island
47b S Ferry Road
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
3
Bd
2
Ba
1,800
SF
Single Family
$3,995,000
$2,219
/SF
Listing by: Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
Listed:
3/13/2024
$3,995,000
date
Price
variance
type
3/13/2024
$3,995,000
--
Listed
1
2
3
Shelter Island South
Location
Map
Draw
Radius