26 Homes for Sale in Shelter Island South

new listing 7 days ago
Shelter Island
44 St Marys Road
Shelter IslandNY 11964
3 Bd4 Ba3,225 SF
Single Family
$3,900,000
$1,209/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:6/20/2024$3,900,000
datePricevariancetype
6/20/2024$3,900,000--Listed
new listing 18 days ago
Shelter Island
3 S Cartwright Road
Shelter IslandNY 11964
Land
$750,000
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:6/9/2024$750,000
datePricevariancetype
6/9/2024$750,000--Listed
new listing 19 days ago
Shelter Island
45 New York Avenue
Shelter IslandNY 11965
4 Bd2 Ba2,628 SF
Single Family
$2,495,000
$949/SF
Listing by: Brown Harris Stevens (East Hampton)
Listed:6/8/2024$2,495,000
datePricevariancetype
6/8/2024$2,495,000--Listed
new listing 22 days ago
Shelter Island
3 Crab Creek Road
Shelter IslandNY 11964
3 Bd3 Ba1,400 SF
Single Family
$2,195,000
$1,568/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:6/5/2024$2,195,000
datePricevariancetype
6/5/2024$2,195,000--Listed
new listing 30 days ago
Shelter Island
4 Gazon Road
Shelter IslandNY 11964
6 Bd4 Ba3,764 SF
Single Family
$3,385,000
$899/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:5/28/2024$3,385,000
datePricevariancetype
5/28/2024$3,385,000--Listed
new listing 35 days ago
Shelter Island
24 Rocky Point Road
Shelter IslandNY 11939
4 Bd3 Ba3,000 SF
Single Family
$3,600,000
$1,200/SF
Listing by: M WEIN REALTY INC
Listed:5/23/2024$3,600,000
datePricevariancetype
5/23/2024$3,600,000--Listed
Shelter Island
8 Crescent Way
Shelter IslandNY 11964
4 Bd3 Ba2,800 SF
Single Family
$2,690,000
$961/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Listed:5/10/2024$2,690,000
datePricevariancetype
5/10/2024$2,690,000--Listed
Sale Under Contract 05-22-24
Shelter Island
18 Dickerson Drive
Shelter IslandNY 11964
4 Bd3 Ba2,774 SF
Single Family
$2,495,000
$899/SF
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Contract:5/22/2024$2,495,000
datePricevariancetype
5/22/2024$2,495,000--Contract
5/4/2024$2,495,000--Listed
Shelter Island
7 Marc Street
Shelter IslandNY 11964
3 Bd2 Ba1,190 SF
Single Family
$1,800,000
$1,513/SF
Listing by: Brown Harris Stevens (Sag Harbor)
Listed:4/21/2024$1,800,000
datePricevariancetype
4/21/2024$1,800,000--Listed
Open House4-6-24|1:00 PM - 3:00 PM
Shelter Island
21 Signs Road
Shelter IslandNY 10314
2 Bd1 Ba750 SF
Condominium
$569,000
$759/SF
Listing by: Exit Realty Professionals
Listed:4/1/2024$569,000
datePricevariancetype
4/1/2024$569,000--Listed
For Sale Price Reduced 06-02-24
Shelter Island
1048 Post Avenue
Shelter IslandNY 10302
7 Bd3 Ba1,984 SF
Single Family
$780,000
$393/SF
Listing by: RE/MAX Edge
decreased:6/2/2024$780,000(2.49%)
datePricevariancetype
6/2/2024$780,000-2.49%decreased
5/2/2024$799,900+9.73%Listed
4/16/2024$729,000--off market
2/27/2024$729,000--Listed
Shelter Island
47b S Ferry Road
Shelter IslandNY 11964
3 Bd2 Ba1,800 SF
Single Family
$3,995,000
$2,219/SF
Listing by: Hedgerow Exclusive Properties
Listed:3/13/2024$3,995,000
datePricevariancetype
3/13/2024$3,995,000--Listed
Shelter Island South
Google Maps Static Image